Scottish Human Rights Law Group

An intervention by THE RIGHT HON LADY JUSTICE ARDEN DBE
Considering the theme for the opening of the legal year of the ECtHR, namely ‘The Convention is Yours’, this address asks whether the Convention is actually such. It considers the problematic reality of domestic law being misunderstood or misinterpreted by Strasbourg, in light of cases such as Osman v United Kingdom, …

[2010] UKSC 7
Although the Crown’s failure to disclose to an accused material which might have materially weakened its case, or materially strengthened the accused’s case, had been incompatible with the European Convention on Human Rights 1950 art.6, that did not mean that the trial had been unfair. An appeal court would find that a trial had been unfair only if …

[2010] UKSC 6
Although the Crown’s failure to disclose outstanding criminal charges relating to one of its witnesses was incompatible with an accused’s rights under the European Convention on Human Rights 1950 art.6(1), there had been no miscarriage of justice as there was no real possibility that the jury would have come to a different verdict if it had been aware …

Contribution by:  Jennifer Spence
Court of Session (Inner House), 21 January 2010
Lord President (Hamilton), Lady Paton, Lord Carloway
Mr K, the unmarried father of a child (“X”), born 6 May 2002, applied to the Sheriff for parental rights and responsibilities in terms of section 11 of the Children (Scotland) Act 1995 (c.36) (“the Act”).  Mr K was named on X’s birth certificate …

A decision not to release a British citizen, who had been convicted by a court in Laos for a drugs offence